What are your thoughts on Signal's policy for edited messages?
Privacy Guides Community [Unofficial]
April 25, 2026
uninvitedfriend:
> Of course, one could always deny any compromisable topic, but a burst of deletion-evident messages (like in WhatsApp or Signal) tied to a specific time frame can suggest involvement in e.g. activistic events, or authoritarian regimes might even consider it obstruction of justice.
This is why perhaps disappearing messages is the best setting for that context.
Deleting specific messages instead of a whole chat, without any notification that there was any change, can also paint a lie in Telegram. I am not convinced that they had privacy in mind with how they implemented this feature.
Telegram, also doesn’t let you see previous version of messages that you edited, but I remember reading somewhere that they have access to it. Also, when they first introduced edited messages, you could edit any old message, even from weeks or months ago.
So again, you could create a lie, even though there would be an indication that the message was edited. I believe that when they updated the feature, they made it so that you couldn’t edit a message after 48 hours, which is still pretty long. With Signal, I believe it’s only a couple of minutes or at best an hour.
Discussion in the ATmosphere