Problem with foot=no on lawfully forbidden streets(Train-Crossing). not verifiable on the Ground
did:plc:4tuge3k3comfj4nfvqnwkemn
May 23, 2026
Hello, just a collection before putting it into a purposal
so there are many issues about walk=no at Gleisanlagen. Each enities pushing it to not my problem.
- Routers need it to avoid Tracking through have traffic with separate sidewalks
- Openstreetmap verifable on the spot
- Historie of foot=no is changing in wikipedia.
- StreetComplete is asking if its forbidden, not if its forbidden by sign.
- Just use access.
Reasons:
- “Just use a better Router”,
- Street-Speed-Limit is also not verifable on the Ground.
- osm.wiki/DE:Key:foot
- https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/poll-should-streetcomplete-disable-the-are-pedestrians-forbidden-to-walk-on-this-road-without-sidewalk-here-quest-in-the-uk/118387
- No router is picking it up
Perfect solution: https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/2472 Are pedestrians legally prohibited from walking here according to a road sign?”
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/foot-no-oft-falsch-erfasst-durch-streetcomplete-quest/95470/6
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/foot-no-prohibited-impossible/5135/25
https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stvo_2013/__25.html (5) Gleisanlagen
Discussion in the ATmosphere