The price of incrementality in k-center clustering

Authors: László Kozma

The $k$-center problem is one of the best-studied and most intuitive clustering formulations. It asks, given a set of $n$ points in a metric space, for $k$ of the points to be designated as cluster centers, so that the maximum distance of an input point to its nearest center is minimized. Gonzalez's greedy algorithm from 1985 is a simple and efficient way to find a $2$-approximate solution. The algorithm has the attractive feature of \emph{incrementality}: it outputs the centers one by one, with a guaranteed $2$-approximation for every prefix of the obtained sequence of centers. Incrementality imposes a geometric constraint on how solutions can be built, and it is natural to ask whether this comes at a price in the quality of the solution. It is known that in polynomial time, the approximation ratio of $2$ is best possible, assuming $P \neq NP$. In this paper we show that even with \emph{unlimited} computational power, the factor $2$ cannot be improved, if the solution is required to be built incrementally. The lower bound construction imposes a tradeoff between all $n$ levels of the clustering simultaneously; it was obtained with the help of ChatGPT, an aspect we discuss in Section 3 of the paper.