Is telling a falsehood always a lie?
Dan Dart's Blog: Software, Mathematics, Radio, Music [Unofficia…
May 4, 2026
Alright, do you see lying as to communicate deliberately what you don’t believe, or to communicate deliberately what isn’t true?
So in other words, is it a lie for someone to unwittingly pass on false information, or are they not lying because they genuinely believe it?
My view on it is that if I were told that Mercury was the hottest planet (a falsehood) and believed it, then told someone, I wouldn’t be lying, even though I’d been misinformed?
Is that the consensus, or would people instead say that lying is based on whether or not something is actually “true” and that I had actually unwittingly lied?
Doesn’t really make sense to me that unwittingly lying is a thing, because one does believe it and isn’t trying to deceive.
Discussion in the ATmosphere